How I Choose Which AI to Use for Each Task: Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini

Robots representing ChatGPT for photos, Claude for article writing and Gemini for simple photos around a person working at a laptop

Written by

in

· Published

Last updated: October 2026

When people ask me which AI they should use, I never give one name. I use several, and each one has a job. It took me some trial and error to find out which job belongs to which tool, and I still change my mind when something new comes out.

This is how I decide which AI to use for each task, which ones I pay for and which ones I would not pay for. It is my own experience, not a lab test, so your results may be different.

The Short Version

  • Claude: I use it for writing articles, for automations, for building web pages and for any job where I need to connect things through APIs.
  • ChatGPT: I use it for images, and from time to time to look up information.
  • Gemini: I used it at the beginning for images. I did not like the results as much, but it is a good free option.
  • What I pay: ChatGPT Plus and a Claude plan, about 20 euros a month each.

My Setup at a Glance

TaskWhat I useWhy
Writing articlesClaudeIt helps me a lot with the writing
Automations and web pagesClaudeI can connect it with many APIs
ImagesChatGPT (Plus)The free plan runs out too fast
Looking up informationChatGPT, from time to timeQuick answers when I need them
Free imagesGeminiMore free credits than ChatGPT

If you want a neutral comparison of these three assistants, see our guide to ChatGPT vs Claude vs Gemini.

Claude: Writing, Automations and Web Pages

Claude is the tool I open most often. It helps me with the articles I write, and I use it when I want to automate something or build a web page. The reason is simple: I can link it with many APIs, so it is not only a chat. It can work with the other tools I use.

It is also the one I use for my store. If you want to see how I connected it, read how I built my Shopify store with Claude Code and Visual Studio Code.

ChatGPT: Images and Quick Searches

For images, the one I use the most is ChatGPT, with the Plus plan. I pay for it because the free version has limits on pictures that get in my way. On the free plan, three or four images were enough to use up the allowance.

I also use ChatGPT from time to time to look for information. It is not the tool I open first for everything, but it is handy for that. If you want to see how it handles images compared with another assistant, we ran a small test in our guide to the best AI image generators.

Gemini: A Good Free Option for Images

I started with Gemini for images. The pictures it made did not convince me very much, so I moved to ChatGPT. But I still think Gemini is a good option if what you want is to keep everything free. It gives you plenty of options for making pictures and many more credits than ChatGPT does on its free plan.

So my honest view is this: it is not the one I would pick for the best-looking images, but it is a very good place to start without spending money. For more free choices, see our list of the best free AI tools.

What I Pay For, and Why

I pay for two plans: ChatGPT Plus, which is 20 euros a month, and a Claude plan, which is also 20 euros a month. I use AI every day for work and for my projects, so for me both are worth it.

Here is how I would put it:

  • If you use AI every day for work or projects: a paid plan is very useful, and the 20-euro level is the one I would start with.
  • If you only use it to look things up in your daily life: the free versions work well enough.

Plans and prices change often, so check the official pages before you subscribe.

How I Decide, Step by Step

  1. I start from the task, not from the tool. Is it writing, building something, looking something up or making an image?
  2. I pick the tool that fits that job. Writing and automations go to Claude. Images go to ChatGPT.
  3. I check the limits. If I would run out of free credits fast, I use the plan that does not make me stop.
  4. I try another tool if I am not happy. That is how I moved from Gemini to ChatGPT for images.

Advice If You Are Starting

  • Do not pay for everything at once. Start with the free versions and see what you really use.
  • Test the same task in two tools. The difference is often easy to see, and it is the cheapest way to decide.
  • Pay only when the limits slow you down. That was my signal.
  • Give each tool a clear role. It saves you time and stops you opening the wrong one.

If you want ready-made examples of what to ask, see our guide to the best ChatGPT prompts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which AI is best for writing?

For me, Claude, because it helps me a lot with my articles. Other people prefer a different tool, so try the free plans on your own writing.

Which AI is best for making images?

I use ChatGPT with the Plus plan. Gemini is a good free alternative, with more free credits, although I liked its pictures less.

Is it worth paying for ChatGPT Plus?

If you make images often or use it every day for work, I think so. If you only use it from time to time, the free plan may be enough.

Do I need to pay for more than one AI?

Not necessarily. I pay for two because I use them every day for different jobs. If you are starting, one is enough.

Can I use only free AI tools?

Yes. The free versions work well for everyday searches and small tasks. You will notice the limits mostly with images and with daily work.

My Take

There is no single best AI. There is the one that fits the job you have in front of you. For me, that means Claude for writing, automations and web pages, ChatGPT for images and some searches, and Gemini as a good free option. Start with the free versions, learn what you actually use, and pay only when the limits begin to slow you down.

Keep Reading

About This Article

This article is independent. I have no sponsorship from Anthropic, OpenAI or Google, and I do not currently earn commissions from the tools mentioned. If that changes, I will say so clearly. It describes my personal experience, which may differ from yours.

Disclaimer: AI products, prices and features change quickly. Always check the official websites before making a decision.

About the author
I’m Christian Serrano, and I run AIVERSUSIA. I sell products online and use AI tools in that work every day. I test tools with the same prompts and publish what happened, including mistakes and limits. Claude helps me write articles and run tests, and I review and approve everything before it is published. More about me · Editorial policy